Post by xyz3000 on Feb 12, 2024 14:05:53 GMT 5.5
The Superior Court of Justice maintained the process that discusses the right of the municipality of Santa Rita (PB) to receive royalties from the National Petroleum Agency for the passage of natural gas pipelines in its territory. With this, the decision of the Federal Regional Court of the 1st Region that determined the payment is maintained. The ordinary action was initially proposed by the municipality in the Judiciary Section of the Federal Court in Paraíba. The injunction was denied. The municipality then filed an appeal, but the Federal Regional Court of the 5th Region denied the request. It understood that the pipes and the city gate (network operation and distribution station) existing in the municipality's territory do not characterize land facilities for loading and unloading natural gas for the purpose of receiving royalties.
Subsequently, the municipality filed a lawsuit with the Judiciary Section of the Federal District. The injunction was also denied. However, when judging the appeal, federal judge Souza Prudente, from the TRF of the 1st Region, determined the payment of royalties , as long as Estonia Email List the form of distribution established in Ordinance 29/2001-ANP was observed, until the merits were decided. The ANP went to the STJ to suspend the decision, arguing that there was a conflict of jurisdiction. Minister Edson Vidigal did not accept the argument. “The conflict of jurisdiction is not an adequate procedural means for terminating the process, as expressly requested by the ANP in the beginning”, observed the president of the STJ.
Even if this were not the case, there is no fumus boni iuris to support the request for an injunction formulated by the ANP, notably because the lis pendens was expressly dismissed by federal judge Souza Prudente, with the conflict not being an appropriate resource to reform this decision”, concluded Edson Vidigal Anyone who believes that piracy can create jobs for less privileged Brazilians is deluded. It is a fact that the majority of counterfeit products consumed in the country are produced beyond our borders, in places as far away as China or as close as Bolivia. Hundreds of Brazilian businesses close annually because they cannot withstand unfair competition from illegally imported products. Perhaps worse for the nation is the damage that piracy causes to its image abroad and its relationship with the world.
Subsequently, the municipality filed a lawsuit with the Judiciary Section of the Federal District. The injunction was also denied. However, when judging the appeal, federal judge Souza Prudente, from the TRF of the 1st Region, determined the payment of royalties , as long as Estonia Email List the form of distribution established in Ordinance 29/2001-ANP was observed, until the merits were decided. The ANP went to the STJ to suspend the decision, arguing that there was a conflict of jurisdiction. Minister Edson Vidigal did not accept the argument. “The conflict of jurisdiction is not an adequate procedural means for terminating the process, as expressly requested by the ANP in the beginning”, observed the president of the STJ.
Even if this were not the case, there is no fumus boni iuris to support the request for an injunction formulated by the ANP, notably because the lis pendens was expressly dismissed by federal judge Souza Prudente, with the conflict not being an appropriate resource to reform this decision”, concluded Edson Vidigal Anyone who believes that piracy can create jobs for less privileged Brazilians is deluded. It is a fact that the majority of counterfeit products consumed in the country are produced beyond our borders, in places as far away as China or as close as Bolivia. Hundreds of Brazilian businesses close annually because they cannot withstand unfair competition from illegally imported products. Perhaps worse for the nation is the damage that piracy causes to its image abroad and its relationship with the world.